Compare Roth and traditional retirement contributions using the same annual pre-tax budget and investment return.
by Calcuatany.com
A Roth contribution is made with after-tax money and qualified withdrawals are generally tax-free. A deductible traditional contribution can use pre-tax money, but withdrawals are generally taxable. A fair comparison therefore needs the same economic budget: if $6,000 is available before tax and the current marginal rate is 22%, the comparable Roth contribution is $4,680 while the traditional contribution is $6,000.
Both accounts are assumed to earn the same investment return. The traditional balance is reduced by the effective withdrawal tax rate at the end; the Roth balance is reduced by the current tax rate before each contribution. Under this simplified same-budget model, the breakeven withdrawal rate equals the current marginal rate. Investment return and time change the dollar difference, but not that breakeven rate.
How to use the Roth vs Traditional IRA
- Enter the annual pre-tax contribution budget. This is the amount available before current income tax, not necessarily the legal IRA contribution limit.
- Enter your marginal tax rate now. The calculator uses it to convert the pre-tax budget into a comparable after-tax Roth contribution.
- Enter the effective tax rate you expect to apply to traditional withdrawals. This may differ from a marginal bracket because retirement withdrawals can span rates.
- Enter the expected annual investment return and years to retirement. Both accounts use the same return and end-of-year annual contributions.
- Compare the Roth value with the traditional after-tax value. Test several tax rates and returns rather than treating one projection as a forecast.
Formula
Roth FV = contribution × (1 − tax now) × annuity factor; Traditional after-tax FV = contribution × annuity factor × (1 − withdrawal tax)
Example: equal tax rates produce equal after-tax values
With a $6,000 annual pre-tax budget and a 22% current rate, the comparable Roth contribution is $4,680 per year. The traditional account receives $6,000 per year. At a 7% return for 30 years, those end-of-year contributions grow to $442,076.48 in the Roth and $566,764.72 before tax in the traditional account.
Applying a 22% withdrawal rate to the traditional balance leaves $442,076.48, equal to the Roth under these assumptions. A withdrawal rate above 22% favours the Roth; a rate below 22% favours the traditional account.
How to interpret the result
The tax-rate comparison drives the result. A current rate below the future effective withdrawal rate favours paying tax now through the Roth; a lower future rate favours deferral through the traditional account.
The dollar projection is highly sensitive to return and time. Those inputs show the scale of the choice, not a guaranteed account balance.
This is a same-pre-tax-budget comparison. Comparing equal nominal deposits instead would give the Roth a larger out-of-pocket cost and would not be an apples-to-apples tax-timing comparison.
Next, you may also find these useful: Retirement Calculator, Compound Interest Calculator, Inflation Calculator.
Assumptions and limitations
- Contributions occur at the end of each year and remain constant. The return is constant, with no fees or investment losses.
- The traditional contribution is assumed deductible at the current marginal rate, and the Roth withdrawal is assumed qualified and tax-free. Eligibility and deductibility rules are not modeled.
- One effective tax rate is applied to the entire traditional balance at withdrawal. Real withdrawals may be spread across years, deductions and tax brackets.
- Contribution limits, income phaseouts, employer plans, required minimum distributions, early-withdrawal rules, state tax and the value of tax diversification are outside the calculation.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the Roth contribution smaller in this comparison?
The calculator holds the pre-tax household budget constant. A $6,000 pre-tax budget at a 22% current tax rate corresponds to $4,680 of after-tax Roth money or $6,000 in a deductible traditional account.
What is the breakeven withdrawal rate?
Under the same-budget and same-return assumptions, it equals the marginal tax rate now. If both are 22%, the projected after-tax values are equal.
Does a higher return automatically favour the Roth?
No. With the same investment and economic budget, return multiplies both sides. The relative result is driven by the current tax rate versus the effective rate on traditional withdrawals.
Why use an effective withdrawal rate?
Traditional withdrawals may fill several brackets and interact with other retirement income. An effective rate is a simplified estimate of the share of the projected balance ultimately paid in tax.
Are IRA contribution limits included?
No. Limits and income rules change and can differ by age and tax year. Enter an amount for which you are eligible and confirm current limits with official guidance.
Can I contribute to both account types?
Potentially, subject to eligibility and combined limits. Holding both can diversify future tax treatment even when one side has a higher projected value in this simplified comparison.
Sources and further reading
Last reviewed: 2026-10-06. See our editorial policy.
Related calculators
Estimates only; not financial, tax or legal advice. Confirm figures with your lender or a licensed professional. Full disclaimer